Problems with Cupcake Texture
(Leechburg, Pennsylvania, USA)
I recently started with my cupcake obsession. On a few of the batches the texture was more muffin like than cake. It was denser than I would have liked. What did I do wrong? The recipe called for sour cream instead of milk. I tried not to over beat the batter. Help please.
Answer: It can be frustrating when your cupcakes don’t turn out the way you planned. Ugh. Sounds like you’ve got cupcakes with a dense texture. While there’s a variety of ways this happens, here are some of the most common reasons:
Cake Structure Doesn’t Develop During Baking | Most cakes are able to develop their light “cake” structure by the way the ingredients are mixed. Cakes rely on the creaming method (creaming the sugar and butter together). Depending on the recipe, you would add wet ingredients next and then dry or alternate wet and dry in the mixing process.
Over Mixing the Batter | Developing the gluten is just want you need for making bread, but in a cake you want to keep the texture tender and light. Most cake recipes will tell you to mix until combined but not over do it. (Sounds like you took precautions to avoid doing this, though.)
Oven Temperature | If you have an oven that doesn’t heat evenly or is too warm, it can cause the cupcake to toughen up. Cupcakes are so tiny, they really can’t afford you much of a margin for error. I often check on my cupcakes about 1 – 2 minutes before they’re meant to be done just to be sure I’m not over baking.
Improper Recipe Proportions | It could be the recipe proportions could be off. Try another version of the same recipe and experiment.